A defendant accused of a hit-and-run murder waived his right to counsel during a hearing before DC Superior Court Judge Todd Edelman on Oct. 28.
Kyle Piunti, 36, is charged with second-degree murder and three counts of assault with a dangerous weapon for his alleged involvement in a vehicular accident that killed 54-year-old Michael Hamlin on Jan. 3, 2024 on Highway I-295 southbound near Mile Marker 1, SW.
At the hearing, Judge Edelman discussed Piunti’s motion to proceed Pro Se– a formal request made to a court for permission to represent oneself in a legal case without an attorney.
If granted, this motion would vacate the appointment of his defense attorney Kevin Irving, who according to Judge Edelman, was the fifth attorney appointed in this case since it opened in September 2024.
Judge Edelman emphasized some of the disadvantages Piunti would encounter without Irving as his attorney. The judge argued that Irving can argue motions–legal requests made to the judge–in a way Piunti cannot, and has better access to the prosecution’s discoveries and evidence.
Additionally, Judge Edelman explained that Irving has expertise in selecting jurors, cross-examining witnesses, and giving opening and closing arguments.
“By giving up Mr. Irving as your lawyer, your defense is going to be weaker,” Judge Edelman said to Piunti.
When asked by Judge Edelman, “What’s your understanding of the prosecution’s theory in this case?” Piunti responded, “I don’t think it’s in my best interest to say.” Piunti then responded, “The prosecution is saying that the vehicle I owned struck somebody.”
Piunti said he understood issues, and asked that Irving be appointed as his stand-by counsel. Irving will be able to handle jury selections and argue certain motions on Piunti’s behalf, according to Judge Edelman.
Judge Edelman granted Piunti’s motion to proceed Pro Se and appointed Irving as his stand-by counsel.
Parties are scheduled to reconvene on Dec. 19.
