A defense attorney argued for a stabbing suspect’s release before DC Superior Court Judge Michael Ryan on Aug. 1.
Troy Scott, 34, is charged with assault with intent to commit murder while armed, aggravated assault knowingly with a grave risk while armed, three counts of assault with a dangerous weapon, and carrying a dangerous weapon. The charges stem from Scott’s alleged involvement in a non-fatal stabbing that occurred on Aug. 5, 2024, on the 1600 block of 29th Street, SE.
Scott’s defense attorney, Rachel Cicurel, argued for his release. She noted that the summer heat and the lack of air conditioning in the DC Jail caused Scott to have two seizures. Cicurel also mentioned Scott’s relocation to a more violent unit was harming his mental health.
Cicurel wanted Scott placed in 24-hour home confinement. Alternatively, she recommended bed-to-bed treatment for mental health with drug testing.
The prosecution argued for Scott’s detention, citing that the defendant repeatedly entered and exited the apartment where the victim was severely injured during the alleged altercation. The prosecution said Scott exited the scene calmly, returned to the apartment allegedly with an axe, and left again with blood covering the blade.
In response, Cicurel argued that the victim attacked first and was known to be violent towards women. The defense also noted that it was not clear how the blood got on the axe. Cicurel also noted that Scott contacted the authorities and got medical assistance for the victim.
Judge Ryan maintained Scott’s detention. He noted that the conditions of the hold did not allow him to consider the defendant’s health issues.
Parties agreed to a medical alert. Judge Ryan stated that he would recommend Scott be transferred to the DC’s Jail’s lower security Central Treatment Facility (CTF).
Parties are slated to reconvene Aug. 29.
