DC Superior Court Judge Robert Hildum revoked a stabbing defendant’s release on Dec 2.
On May 25, 2022 Gabriel Esquina, 23, pleaded guilty to aggravated assault knowingly for his involvement in the stabbing of his child’s mother that occurred on Dec. 29, 2021 on the 2800 block of Myrtle Avenue NE.
Esquina was recently re-arrested after allegedly violating a stay-away order imposed by the court.
The defense, Henry Escoto, argued for Esquina’s release, citing his compliance with the Pretrial Services Agency (PSA), including checking in twice a week. Escoto explained that the violation of the stay-away order occurred after Esquina’s parents invited him back to their home.
He emphasized that his parents had only contacted the police because they felt they needed legal intervention. Escoto added that they are now concerned about Esquina’s mental health and have expressed support for his continued treatment.
Furthermore, Escoto pointed out that Esquina had expressed a willingness to participate in release conditions, including anger management and mental health classes. He proposed the option of electronic monitoring as a means to ensure compliance with any further conditions.
In response, the prosecution argued against Esquina’s release. Simpson noted that Esquina’s charge of felony contempt was serious and emphasized the violation of the stay-away order. The prosecution also highlighted Esquina’s ongoing legal supervision for various other serious offenses and pointed to a history of “spotty compliance” with pre-trial conditions.
The prosecution argued that these factors warranted the continued detention of Esquina. Escoto countered by reiterating that the stay-away violation was not intentional but rather a result of family intervention.
Judge Hildum, however, expressed concern over Esquina’s prior history, mentioning allegations from other cases that he found “concerning.” While agreeing with the prosecution’s position on the seriousness of the case, Judge Hildum noted that Esquina’s mental health concerns and his willingness to participate in treatment were factors to consider.
Ultimately, Judge Hildum revoked Esquina’s release.
The parties are slated to reconvene on Dec. 10.
