Thank you for reading D.C. Witness.
Help us continue our mission into 2025 by donating to our end of year campaign.
By
Phoebe McConnell
, Marissa Stambaugh - October 28, 2024
Daily Stories
|
stabbing
|
DC Superior Court Judge Robert Okun delayed a stabbing defendant’s sentencing on Oct. 25, after he said in a pre-sentencing report he acted in self-defense.
On Aug. 28, Carlton Davis, 48, pleaded guilty to assault with significant bodily injury for his involvement in the stabbing of a victim’s hand with a pair of scissors on July 13, 2024 at the 200 block of 35th Street, SE.
During the hearing, the prosecution requested Judge Okun impose 18 months incarceration, arguing that Davis is a danger to the community. The prosecution argued on the victim’s behalf, stating that the victim’s life was significantly impacted as he had to receive stitches in his hand, was burdened by medical costs, and that his young children were traumatized by witnessing the incident.
Davis had prior burglary convictions and had spent 15 years incarcerated. The prosecutor argued this proves he continues to pose a threat to the community.
Defense attorney Chidi Ogolo argued that Davis could be a productive citizen since he completed his GED and 18 months of college education courses and job training while incarcerated. Ogolo requested a sentence of 14 months of incarceration with six months suspended.
Meanwhile, Davis argued he acted in self-defense, stating that the victim had been acting aggressively at his back door, and he “started swinging uncontrollably,” which allegedly led Davis to grab the scissors and strike him. Davis told Judge Okun he is partially disabled due to being struck by a vehicle.
Davis said he victim is a good person but turns into someone else when he is drunk. Davis claims he “didn’t really mean to hurt [him]” and that he was using the scissors to defend himself, taking full responsibility for picking up the scissors.
Judge Okun asked the defense and prosecution to investigate further and for the defense to file a motion to withdraw a guilty plea if this is the case.
Parties are set to reconvene on Dec 3.