DC Superior Court Judge Robert Hildum ordered a defendant held in a street fight stabbing case after she waived her right to a preliminary hearing on March 30.
Jasmine Berliner, 23, is charged with assault with a dangerous weapon for her alleged involvement in a stabbing that occurred on the 700 block of 8th Street, NE. The victim sustained wounds to his chest, shoulder, arm, and hand and was unconscious at the scene.
According to court documents, Berliner and the victim were reportedly in a heated argument when the victim slapped her. Berliner then allegedly pulled out a knife and stabbed the victim.
During the hearing, Berliner’s attorney, Adam Harris, informed parties that his client waived her right to a preliminary hearing of the evidence against her.
Harris then requested Berliner’s release, arguing that the incident began as a mutual confrontation in which both individuals voluntarily entered alley. Harris stated that the victim initiated physical contact by slapping Berliner, and that Berliner retaliated by escaping the situation and stabbing them.
Harris emphasized that Berliner is a young woman with minimal criminal history, noting a prior 2023 assault conviction in Rhode Island, and argued she is not inherently dangerous. Harris also highlighted her ties to the community, stable housing with a roommate, and assured the court she would stay away from the victim if released.
The prosecution presented photos of the victim’s injuries. They argued that although the victim initiated the physical altercation, Berliner’s use of a knife significantly escalated the violence. Citing the severity of the injuries and the nature of the offense, the prosecution requested that Berliner remain detained.
Judge Hildum stated, “there are no rules in a street fight, but there are still laws.” He also noted allegations from the victim that Berliner referred to the victim as “swiss cheese” and mocked the person following the incident. While acknowledging Berliner’s work skills and stable living situation, Judge Hildum determined that the seriousness of the offense warranted continued detention.
The next hearing is scheduled for April 20.
