Judge Deems Stabbing Defendant Too Dangerous For Release

By Kelsey Ball - October 21, 2024
Daily Stories | Data | Domestic Violence | stabbing | Suspects |

D.C. Superior Court Judge Brandt deemed a stabbing defendant too dangerous to be released during his preliminary hearing on Oct. 10. 

James Callen III, 40, is charged with assault with intent to kill while armed and aggravated assault knowingly while armed for his alleged involvement in a stabbing incident that occurred on July 13. It is unclear where the incident occurred in the District.  

During the hearing, Alvin Thomas Jr., Callen’s attorney, alerted Judge Brandt of his intent to waive his right to the preliminary hearing. Thomas asked the court to consider releasing Callen to house arrest and GPS monitoring.

The prosecution expressed concern that Callen was not a “good candidate for release” and requested he remain held because of his criminal history, highlighting past assault, domestic violence, and contempt charges.

A victim attended the hearing remotely and expressed worry about the defendant being’s release while awaiting trial. The individual alleged that Callen “brutally attacked” and “tried to stab [them] to death.” 

The victim explained that this was not the first time Callen had harmed them and would not be the last if he was released. The victim went on to explain that Callen had been contacting them from jail and threatening to harm them and their loved ones if he was released. 

Prosecutors provided evidence of the injuries the victim endured during the assault. The photos showcased the victim’s stab wounds and blood stains at the scene, where prosecutors claimed they almost bled out.

Judge Brandt ruled that Callen would stay in custody awaiting trial. Judge Brandt explained that his history of violence and contempt of requirements showed that he could not be trusted to follow court directives. Releasing him on house arrest with GPS would put the victim in danger, Judge Brandt concluded.

Parties alerted Judge Brandt they’re in plea negotiations.

Parties are set to convene on Nov. 7.