Judge Finds Probable Cause for Murder in Love Triangle Case

By Rosie Rohrer [former] - June 22, 2023
Court | Daily Stories | Domestic Violence | Homicides | Shooting | Suspects | Victims |

In an emotional hearing before DC Superior Court Judge Rainey Brandt on June 22, both parties debated probable cause in a murder case.

Stephon Shields, 26, is charged with second-degree murder for his alleged involvement in James Samuels’ death, which occurred on June 2 in an apartment on the 2900 block of Nelson Place, SE. 

According to court documents, Shields had an argument with a woman at the scene who was simultaneously in a relationship with Shields and Samuels, prior to Shields entering the residence and engaging in a tussle with Samuels.  

A few moments later, witnesses heard gunshots and Samuels was found dead.

The lead detective on the case from the Metropolitan Police Department (MPD), described interviews with witnesses for their versions of what happened. Several allegedly saw the defendant enter the apartment, and leave moments after the shooting with a firearm.

Given the evidence prosecutors said there was probable cause that Shields is guilty in the case,

Defense attorney Sylvia Smith argued that there was confusion and conflicting witness testimony that cast doubt on the defendant’s involvement in the murder.

Ultimately, Judge Brandt ruled that there was enough evidence to find probable cause that Shields was the perpetrator.

The next question was whether Shields should be released from pretrial confinement.  The prosecution brought up Shields’ previous conviction for fleeing a police officer in 2022.  Smith argued that Shields wasn’t a flight risk if kept on home confinement, and presented four letters of support from Shields’ family members and friends.

However, Judge Brandt ruled that, for the safety of the witnesses in the case, all known to Shields, and and the community at large, Shields will remain incarcerated until his trial. 

Shields responded emotionally to the finding and broke down in tears when faced with the reality of being apart from his home and community.

Parties will return on July 20.