Judge Finds Substantial Probability Man Shot Member of Paving Crew

By D.C. Witness Staff - May 14, 2019
Court | Daily Stories | Homicides | Suspects |

During a preliminary hearing May 13, a DC Superior Court judge found substantial probability that a 29-year-old man intentionally killed a man nearly twice his age.

Terrance Barnes is charged with premeditated first-degree murder while armed for his alleged role in the death of 57-year-old Barry Holmes on the 5100 block of Southern Avenue, SE on April 17.

Judge Craig Iscoe said he made his decision based on the evidence outlined in court documents. Judge Iscoe said Barnes intentionally followed Holmes and pulled out a gun. He said Barnes made no attempt to retreat at any point.

According to the lead detective, Holmes was working with a paving crew on Southern Avenue. The detective said a witness told police Barnes and Holmes got into an argument and that Holmes walked away. Another witness said Barnes later followed Holmes, there was a struggle and that a gun went off.

Court documents state that, during a police interview, Barnes admitted that he and Holmes got into an argument. According to the defense, the argument stemmed from Holmes insulting Barnes’ religion. Apparently, Barnes said he walked away to “cool off” but that he later returned and continued arguing with Holmes.

Barnes told police that he had a gun and that he pulled it out because Holmes swung a street sign at him. Barnes said they struggled with the gun and that Holmes pulled the trigger, shooting himself in the process.

Defense attorney, Jeffrey Stein, refuted the judge’s ruling, arguing that Barnes had no intention of shooting Holmes and that his client only pulled out a gun to “display force.” Stein said there was one shot and that it was fired at Holme’s chest and not his back, which is consistent with a struggle.

Judge Iscoe noted Barnes’ lack of a criminal history. He referenced letters written in support of Barnes release, including a letter from his step-son who credits his 3.5 high school GPA to Barnes’ active role in his life. However, Judge Iscoe said he has a “great deal of concern” regarding the danger Barnes presents to the community.

Judge Iscoe ordered Barnes held without bail and noted that Barnes confessed to police following the shooting that he fled, threw the murder weapon in a river and burned his clothes. Judge Iscoe said Barnes’ actions indicate impulsiveness and an inability to follow the law.

The judge also noted two unrelated 2017 civil protective orders. While the cases were ultimately dismissed, Judge Iscoe said the orders were based on threatening and impulsive behavior. Apparently, Holmes choked and punched his girlfriend and threatened to “blow her away.” Judge Iscoe said Holmes also threatened to beat up the girlfriend and her parents.

Barnes is scheduled for a felony status hearing on July 19.